
CMMS Comparison Chart: How to Score Maintenance Software
This CMMS comparison chart gives maintenance managers and small business owners a simple way to compare computerised maintenance management systems side by side. Score each vendor against the same 12 criteria, add up the results and take a shortlist of three into paid trials. It works whether you maintain a single factory, a fleet of trucks or a group of buildings.
Who This Comparison Chart Is For
The chart is written for small and medium-sized businesses that want a CMMS that is easy to deploy, affordable to run and reliable on an ordinary internet connection. If your team currently tracks maintenance on paper or in spreadsheets, the criteria below will show you what to ask for. If you already use a system, they will show where it falls short.
The CMMS Comparison Chart: 12 Criteria
Print this table, add one column per vendor, and score each row from 1 (poor) to 5 (excellent).
| # | Criterion | What to look for | Question to ask the vendor |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Work order management | Raise, prioritise, assign and close tickets; track MTBR and MTBF | Can a technician close a ticket in under a minute? |
| 2 | Preventive maintenance scheduling | Create, reschedule and close planned tasks by date or usage | Can we change schedules ourselves, without the vendor? |
| 3 | Asset register | Category, location, warranty and serial number for every asset | Can we import our existing Excel asset list? |
| 4 | Spares inventory | Spares grouped by family, with reorder levels, minimum order quantities and lead times | Does it warn us before a critical spare runs out? |
| 5 | Mobile access | Work orders and spares visible on a phone, on the shop floor | Does it work well on a basic Android phone? |
| 6 | Alerts and messaging | Rule-based alerts, plus status queries over WhatsApp | Which events can trigger an alert, and who receives it? |
| 7 | Reports and analytics | Maintenance cost, asset utilisation, response time and trends, with filters | Can we export reports to Excel or PDF? |
| 8 | ERP and accounting integration | Standard integration with your ERP and accounts software | Which systems are supported, and at what extra cost? |
| 9 | Security and access control | User roles and access rights, with data encryption | Can we limit what technicians and managers can see? |
| 10 | Low bandwidth and hosting | Works on a weak internet link, with reliable and affordable cloud hosting | What happens to work orders when the connection drops? |
| 11 | Implementation, training and support | Setup help, user training and support you can reach in your time zone | Who supports us on site, and how fast are spares available? |
| 12 | Pricing model | Subscription or perpetual licence, with a clear three-year total | What is the total cost over three years, including support? |
How to Use This CMMS Comparison Chart
First, give each criterion a weight from 1 to 3 based on what matters to your site. A fleet workshop may weight mobile access and spares at 3, while a plant with strict audits may weight reports and access control at 3. Second, score every vendor from a live demo, not a brochure. Third, multiply score by weight and add up the totals. Fourth, take the top three into a paid trial with your own asset list and a real week of work orders. Our buyer guide for CMMS software selection covers the selection process step by step, and this chart is the scorecard that goes with it.
What Good Looks Like on the Core Rows
The first four rows decide whether the system will actually be used. Technicians need to raise and close work orders quickly, and managers need to see overdue preventive tasks at a glance. Read our guide to work order management in a CMMS to see how a good workflow runs, and preventive maintenance best practices for scheduling that reduces breakdowns. For a longer list of capabilities, see the essential features of a CMMS, and how to use CMMS software in daily work.
Fleet operators should weigh the spares and mobile rows highly. Our page on truck fleet maintenance CMMS software explains how fleet maintenance differs from fixed-site maintenance. If you want status queries and alerts on a messaging app, check the WhatsApp CMMS integration.
RTLS Integration: Faster Dispatch and Automatic Work Orders
RTLS integration links your maintenance system to the real-time location of machines, vehicles and tools. With BLE RTLS, a technician can see where an asset is, so dispatch is faster. A machine downtime dashboard can show open tickets, the machine location, a panic button and a buzzer, and work orders can be triggered by BLE readings as well as by maintenance schedules. It also supports lone-worker safety. Our CMMS runs on the same BLE RTLS infrastructure as our warehouse and yard platforms, and you can read more on the CMMS asset management with RTLS and preventive maintenance CMMS software pages. For the location hardware itself, see the RipplesIPS RTLS platform from Ripples IoT. Ask every vendor whether RTLS needs new cabling, because a wire-free system keeps installation cheap and quick.
Demand Forecasting for Spares Inventory
Reorder levels tell you when stock is low, but demand forecasting tells you how much you will need next. Using past work orders and breakdown history, a forecast can show which spares are used every month and which are used once a year, so you hold more of the first and less of the second. That frees cash and reduces emergency purchases that stop a line. Ask each vendor whether spares forecasts are built in, which data they use, and whether you can export the reorder list. To understand the method behind it, read our guide to demand forecasting software. For critical spares, always keep a safety stock, whatever the forecast says.
Pricing Models: Subscription or Perpetual
CMMS vendors usually sell either a subscription or a perpetual licence. A subscription spreads the cost and normally includes hosting and updates, while a perpetual licence has a larger upfront price and separate fees for support. Compare both over three years, and ask for a paid trial or demo before you commit. Good asset management practice, as set out in the ISO 55000 asset management standard, starts with knowing what you own and what it costs to keep running, so make sure the reports row of your chart can show that.
Common Mistakes When Comparing CMMS Software
- Scoring from brochures instead of a live demo with your own data.
- Choosing the longest feature list instead of the system technicians will actually open.
- Ignoring what happens when the internet connection drops.
- Forgetting training, support and the availability of local spares.
- Comparing the first-year price only, not the three-year total.
Have a Project in Mind? Let’s Talk
If you would like to see how the 12 criteria apply to your own site, contact our team and bring your asset list and a typical week of maintenance tasks.

